UW Wisconsin study says surgeons are wary of advance directives

A recent study by a University of Wisconsin Madison surgical professor suggests that advance directives, or "living wills," may impede the work of surgeons, even causing some to refuse treatment of those with advance directives preventing the use of extraordinary measures.

The findings of the study were published online by Annals of Surgery and later in a University of Wisconsin Madison news release on Thursday. Some have said the study is "troubling."

According to the study, high-risk surgeons may find themselves in a difficult situation when trying to save the life of an individual who has expressed a desire to forgo extraordinary measures. Because of this, only 50 percent of surgeons who do high-risk operations discuss advance directive with their patient prior to surgery. And 54 percent said they wouldn't operate on a patient if had a directive limiting the use of life support in post-operative care, in cases where the surgeon believed it would be necessary for the patient's survival.

The study was based on a survey of over 900 cardiothoracic surgeons, vascular surgeons and neurosurgeons. All the surgeons who participated said they discussed to possibility of a poor outcome with their patients, and nearly all of them said they discuss the need for post-operative life-supporting therapy.

Only 52 percent of the doctors said they asked patients if they had written advance directives. Some surgeons say they do not believe that going by an advance directive works well for surgery, and that it is preferable to have a conversation with the patient about their priorities in the event something goes poorly.

The study, while it does not undermine the importance and value of advance directives as an estate planning tool, does indicate the need to be in better dialogue with one's surgeon about goals and priorities.

Source: The Cap Times, "Can 'living wills' tie a surgeon's hands? UW study indicates so," Bill Novak, January 26, 2012.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Mr. Teiger, Thank you very much for your time and results. I will definitely recommend you & your firm to anyone who wants to be treated professionally courteously and needs results.Hope all is well.Again...thank you. Regards, Paul L.

msg iconEmail Us For a Response

When you have legal questions or concerns, contact our team at Teiger Law Center, P.C., by calling 678-374-7645, 800-780-2275 or reach us via email by completing our online contact form. From our Cumming and Alpharetta law offices, we represent clients in the Atlanta metro and throughout north Georgia.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information
disclaimer.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

close

Privacy Policy

Cumming Office
514 West Maple Street
Suite 101
Cumming, GA 30040

Toll Free: 866-726-2153
Phone: 678-374-7645
Fax: 770-406-8858
Cumming Law Office Map

Alpharetta Office
12600 Deerfield Parkway, Suite 100
Alpharetta, GA 30004

Toll Free: 800-780-2275
Phone: 678-374-7645
Fax: 770-406-8858
Map & Directions

Review Us